Professor George Land gives an inspiring TED talk into his research of creativity in children and adults, with some shocking findings about how creativity levels change throughout a child’s life.
Watch the video above, and then see the discussion below.
The nature vs nurture debate is one that is ongoing and many studies have been conducted around it. One famous one is George Land’s Creativity Test, which he outlines in his new book Breakpoint and Beyond.
In 1968, George Land (with Beth Jarman) conducted a research study to test the creativity of 1,600 children ranging in ages from three-to-five years old who were enrolled in a Head Start program. This was the same creativity test he devised for NASA to help select innovative engineers and scientists. The assessment worked so well he decided to try it on children. He re-tested the same children at 10 years of age, and again at 15 years of age (a longitudinal study).
The test was to look at a problem and come up with new, different, innovative ideas
The results were astounding. The proportion of people who scored at the “Genius Level”, were:
- amongst 5 year olds: 98%
- amongst 10 year olds: 30%
- amongst 15 year olds: 12%
- Same test given to 280,000 adults (average age of 31): 2%
According to Land, the primary reason for this is that there are two types of thinking processes when it comes to creativity:
- Convergent thinking: where you judge ideas, criticise them, refine them, combine them and improve them, all of which happens in your conscious thought
- Divergent thinking: where you imagine new ideas, original ones which are different from what has come before but which may be rough to start with, and which often happens subconsciously
He notes that throughout school, we are teaching children to try and use both kinds of thinking at the same time, which is impossible.
Competing neurons in the brain will be fighting each other, and it is as if your mind is having a shouting match with itself.
Instead of this, Land suggests we need to allow people to split their thinking processes into the various different states, to make each of them more effective.
It’s something which all of my own learning strongly correlates with as well, and which I speak about in my own lectures.
So if you want your child to retain their ability and desire to be creative, encourage them to let their mind run free while they come up with ideas, and only afterwards to sit down, evaluate them and start working on the ones they think are the best.
Do you like insights into creativity like this?
Then sign up for your FREE account from Idea to Value to not only get great pieces of insight like this every week, but also free training on improving your creativity and company innovation capabilities from some of the world’s leading innovation experts.
Did you notice your own creativity levels drop during school, or those of your child? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to share and follow us on Facebook and Twitter.
Nick Skillicorn
Latest posts by Nick Skillicorn (see all)
- Self-Serving bias: Why you think nothing is your fault - August 9, 2023
- We are all sheep - August 2, 2023
- Planning fallacy: Why we are so bad at predicting how long something will take - July 27, 2023
- Pygmalion effect: The self-fulfilling prophecy - July 24, 2023
[…] According to Land, there are two types of creative thinking, divergent and convergent. Divergent thinking means that you created the thought, rather than just observing the thought. Unfortunately, in schools, we are teaching children both types of thinking, which is impossible to be learned at the same time. Instead, Land believes that if we allowed people to split their thinking processes into various different states, to make each of them more effective. […]
[…] https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] […]
[…] https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] you do a Google search on creativity, you’ll pretty quickly run into an article that mentions a study run by Professor George Land that seems to show that children become less creative over […]
[…] at MossyBrain, we subscribe to the idea that we are all born creative. Dr. George Land and Beth Jarman developed an experiment to test creative potential, measuring the ability to come up with […]
[…] recently read about this now-famous study, 1,500 students (ages 3-5) were asked this question. The higher the number of possibilities you […]
[…] said that all children are artists, with the trick being to remain an artist once we grow up. A seminal study by George Land showed this with frightening clarity in 1968, the year of my […]
[…] common belief that “some people are just born more creative than others,” I cited the famous study by George Land showing the radical tendency toward creative downturns as children grow up. This has been, by the […]
[…] common belief that “some people are just born more creative than others,” I cited the famous study by George Land showing the radical tendency toward creative downturns as children grow up. This has been, by the […]
[…] said that all children are artists, with the trick being to remain an artist once we grow up. A seminal study by George Land showed this with frightening clarity in 1968, the year of my […]
[…] Evidence shows that our kids creativity declines with age, because of many factors, including being told NOT to do things too often. For what we can do to keep our kids creative and smart for longer, check out this amazing article and video . […]
[…] 5 Year-olds as Creative GeniusesGeorge Landhttps://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
George is inspiring. Completely accessible and thought provoking. I shall ponder on the words of this old sage when I return to teaching – and act upon what he has so succinctly made clear.
[…] 原文連結:https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] proving successful on the NASA engineers, researchers decided to turn the test on children, so they tested 1,600 four and five year old children. The test looks at the ability to come up with new and innovative ideas to problems. Researchers […]
[…] https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] at the Ontario College of Art & Design (OCAD) University in Toronto, Canada, I learned a statistic that I could not stop thinking about: Children have the greatest capacity for creation at the age […]
[…] Main Study (Kindergarteners longitudinal) https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] do a Google search on creativity, you’ll pretty quickly run into an article that mentions a study run by Professor George Land that seems to show that children become less creative over […]
Hi, can you tel me where I can finde the study? Interested in taking a closer look at it. Greetings Katrín
HI Katrin. Watch the video by Georg Land in the blog above, and I have also included a link to his book where he describes the study. I hope that helps.
[…] according to a famous 1962 study by George Land 8, creativity can also be ‘unlearnt’. Land argued that the modern educational system, which was […]
[…] George Land’s Creativity Test concludes that non-creative behavior is learned. Source: Idea To Value […]
[…] recherche Google sur la créativité, vous tomberez assez rapidement sur un article qui mentionne une étude menée par le professeur George Land qui semble montrer que les enfants deviennent moins créatifs avec le […]
[…] on the Ontario Faculty of Artwork & Design (OCAD) College in Toronto, Canada, I realized a statistic that I couldn’t cease fascinated about: Youngsters have the best capability for creation on […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Pupil creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent considering. Primarily, the college studying expertise is targeted on convergent considering, the place the product is emphasised and never the method. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Main Study (Kindergarteners longitudinal) https://www.ideatovalue.com/crea/nickskillicorn/2016/08/evidence-children-become-less-creative-time-… […]
[…] Students’ interests, strengths, and loves are often not included in the learning experience at school. (Gallup) Students experience an “answer-centric” learning environment, where getting the answer right is more important than what questions the student may have. (Make Just One Change) Student creativity has been impacted over time by the absence of divergent thinking. Primarily, the school learning experience is focused on convergent thinking, where the product is emphasized and not the process. (Breakpoint and Beyond) […]
[…] Evidence that children become less creative over time (and how to fix it) […]
[…] instincts, however, seem to diminish over time. Psychologists George Land and Beth Jarman conducted a landmark study in 1968 which tested creativity in 16,000 children. The test was designed for NASA to identify innovative […]
[…] are skills needed for many jobs, yet kids seem to lose creativity as they get older. (Check out this awesome TedTalk about a NASA Creativity test that proves people become less creative). Math, especially, is an area […]
[…] on the Ontario School of Artwork & Design (OCAD) College in Toronto, Canada, I discovered a statistic that I couldn’t cease excited about: Youngsters have the best capability for creation on the […]
[…] to a study done by Dr. George Land and Dr. Beth Harman, 98% of preschoolers are creative […]
[…] recherche Google sur la créativité, vous tomberez assez rapidement sur un article qui mentionne les travaux du professeur George Land, avançant que les enfants perdent en créativité au fil des […]
[…] the issue of creative thinking being ignored in our educational systems has become widespread. One famous study proves this with alarming results. As children we are bursting with creative thoughts. But by the […]